There is a real tension between talking and doing. In the present election cycle, establishment politicians are the talkers, and who are the doers? Well, Trump and his supporters, who are going to “make America great again.” But notice that just as politicians have their reputation for not getting anything done, Trump and his supporters have their reputation for being unthoughtful and inarticulate. You have to be one or the other, you can’t be a talker and a doer.
The Bible says that there is a time to gather stones and a time to scatter them. There is obviously a time for talking and a time for doing. Talking implies delayed action. When action is needed, somebody needs to declare that the conversation is over. On 9/11, Todd Beamer said to his fellow passengers “Let’s roll” before taking on the highjackers of Flight 93.
When people are in danger or pain, it is hard to argue that the conversation should continue. Pain demands a response. Pain demands action. If my arms are full of groceries, and I suddenly feel an ant biting my ankle, then I’m dropping those groceries, milk and eggs be damned. If I’m addicted to drugs, and my addiction generates extreme pain when I’m off the drug, then I’m taking the drug.
Conversation is an activity of the mind, while doing is an expression of the heart. It is the heart that needs to be convinced by the mind, not vice-versa. The default mode is to do, and to do immediately. If the mind can make a compelling case that action should be put off, that more thought needs to be had, then patience can be achieved — for a while. But if the heart has to wait too long it loses faith in the ability of the mind to deliver on its promises, and the heart will go it alone. It can be tragic when this happens.
The saying is true that love is blind. The heart might know what it wants, but it has no idea how to get it or to keep it. The heart wants love and affection, but without the mind the pursuit of love and affection from another can become creepy. It’s a turn off for the beloved. The mind says wait, the heart says go. The mind says settle down, the heart says reach out, demand, force. The heart reveals its own desperation, its weakness, its vulnerability, its willingness to give up everything. The heart is a self-destructive beggar. The mind of the beloved asks: why give this beggar my heart? What here is worth wanting? The world is indifferent, it says, “that’s not how this works.”
All lasting love is led and informed by the mind. This is why communication is so important in marriage as it is in politics. In marriage, our hearts want love, but our mind says first be worthy of love, be virtuous. This is frustrating, and tests the trust between the heart and the mind. In politics, our hearts want happiness, but our mind says first have a successful marriage, have a great job, have dignity, have respect. This is frustrating, and generates resentment after resentment as marriages fail, jobs are lost, and with them, dignity and self-respect. It gives charge to the self-destructive beggars within us, with frustration giving way to recklessness, failure, and a nod towards death.
We need to protect our hearts and ourselves by being patient and open-minded. There are ways–some clever, others straightforward–to satisfy our hearts and sooth our frustrations, but we can never make the best use of them if we close ourselves off from the wisdom of the world. This is why talking matters, in marriage and in politics. It takes us from quick and easy assumptions to a winning strategy that can go the distance. Isn’t that what we all want?